3 Reasons Why the Buffalo Bills Shouldn’t Extend RB James Cook
Buffalo, NY – March 2, 2025
The Buffalo Bills have an important decision to make regarding their starting running back, James Cook. As Cook approaches the end of his rookie contract, many fans and analysts are wondering whether the team should offer him an extension. While he has been a key part of the offense, there are compelling reasons why Buffalo should think twice before committing long-term to the young running back. Here are three reasons why the Bills shouldn’t extend James Cook.
1. The Short Shelf Life of Running Backs
The harsh reality of the NFL is that running backs have one of the shortest career spans in professional football. While Cook has been productive, history has shown that investing heavily in running backs on second contracts often leads to diminishing returns. The Bills may be better off using their cap space on more durable positions and finding a younger, cheaper option in the draft.
2. Buffalo’s Pass-Heavy Offense
The Bills’ offense revolves around Josh Allen and the passing game, making a high-priced running back less of a necessity. Buffalo has consistently ranked among the league leaders in pass attempts, and while Cook has provided solid production, he is not the centerpiece of the offense. The team could get similar production from a committee approach at a much lower cost.
3. Salary Cap Constraints
Buffalo is facing tough salary cap decisions in the coming years, especially with star players like Josh Allen and Stefon Diggs carrying hefty contracts. Allocating significant money to a running back could prevent the Bills from retaining key pieces on both sides of the ball. Instead of committing big money to Cook, Buffalo could use those resources to strengthen the offensive line, improve the defense, or add more weapons in the passing game.
Final Verdict
While James Cook has been a solid contributor for the Bills, the business side of the NFL suggests that extending him may not be the best move. With a deep pool of running backs available in the draft each year and Buffalo’s offensive philosophy prioritizing the passing game, the team might be better off letting Cook walk when his contract expires.
What do you think? Should the Bills extend James Cook, or is it time to look for his replacement? Let us know in the comments!